Gigabit LAN vs. 100 Mbps Lan

Posted: October 17th, 2010 | Author: | Filed under: network, QNap | Tags: , , , , , , , | No Comments »

Having recently upgraded my home network to Gigabit speeds, I still had my old devices and cables around. Most of these were specced at 100Mbps, so now I had the perfect opportunity to do a head to head benchmark showing if the upgrade was worth the effort. I expected a significant performance improvement by replacing the old 100 Mbps router from my ISP, which acted as the hub for every wired and wireless device on my network, with a brand new Gigabit switch. As benchmark, I transferred a 2.3 GB file from my PC to a QNap TS-239 NAS 3 times over the router and switch respectively.
These are the average speeds.

.
Name Speed in MB/s Total Tx Time
NetGear VVG2000 Router 10.9 3:37
TrendNet TEG-S80G 51,9 0:44
.

A significant improvement: The transfer is almost 5 times as fast over the Gigabit switch. The measured transfer speed through the NetGear router corresponds well with its specified maximum of 100 Mbps (~12MB/s). With the Gigabit switch, the harddisks of the PC and NAS  become the bottlenecks, since we are nowhere near the theoretical maximum of  a Gigabit network (120 MB/s).

As a part of the upgrade, I also bought new Cat-6 cables. The oldest cable I still had in use was a Cat-5 and crimbed together by myself about 10 years ago. Since Cat-5 is generally not recommended for Gigabit networks, I thought it would be interesting to see just how much using these old cables would affect transfer speed.

.
Cable Speed in MB/s Total Tx Time
Cat-6, 7m, Round 51.4 45.8
Cat-6, 10 m, UltraFlat 51.9 45.4
Cat-5, 5 m, round 51.5 45.7
.

To my surprise, the old Cat-5 cable was on par with the new Cat-6 cables! Luckily, there was not much of the Cat-5 cable to replace, so I won’t be beating myself up over making a useless investment…

I also tested some “UltraFlat” Cat-6 cable, which I was worried would be susceptible to crosstalk, but as the table clearly shows, the performance of the “UltraFlat” cables are equal to that of the regular, round ones.

So, the morale of story is: Don’t be affraid to use UltraFlat cables in your Gigabit network and if you have some old Cat-5 cable buried under your floor or in the wall: Test it with some Gigabit devices before going out of your way to replace it.


TS-239 Pro II Turbo NAS

Posted: October 14th, 2010 | Author: | Filed under: QNap | Tags: | No Comments »

This page details my QNap NAS setup and is primarily a reminder to myself of how to install and configure the applications running on it.

Applications installed through QPKG

Applications installed through IPKG

Web Applications

Applications on the PC

iPhone

Not installed anymore

Local links

Misc. Setup

Coming up